When a stranger visits your website, they are weighing a simple question: can I trust this business? Anything you write about yourself is, understandably, taken with a grain of salt. What other customers say about you counts for much more. A short, honest testimonial from a real customer can do more to reassure a visitor than a page of polished descriptions.
But testimonials only work when they are genuine, and in Canada there are rules about misleading claims. This guide explains how to ask for testimonials, what to do about permission, how to display them well and what to avoid.
Testimonials, reviews and case studies: what is the difference?
- Testimonials are statements from customers that you collect and publish on your own website or materials, usually with permission.
- Reviews are posted by customers on platforms you do not control, such as Google. You can reply to them, but you cannot edit them. See our guide to getting more Google reviews and handling the bad ones.
- Case studies are longer accounts of a specific project, covering the problem, what you did and what happened. They require more effort and more careful agreement from the customer.
Each has a place. This post focuses on testimonials you collect and display yourself.
Keep it real: the most important rule
Never invent a testimonial, edit one to say something the customer did not say, or publish a quote you cannot trace to a real person who agreed to it. This is not only a matter of ethics. The Competition Bureau of Canada has warned that anyone who writes, or permits the writing of, reviews that give a false or misleading impression to consumers could be liable under the Competition Act. The Bureau has also pointed out that employees who post reviews should disclose their connection to the business, and that businesses may be responsible for misleading reviews posted by their staff.
In practical terms:
- Do not write testimonials yourself, and do not ask staff, friends or family to post glowing reviews that do not disclose their connection.
- Do not offer to pay for positive testimonials, or to buy only the good ones, without being clear about the arrangement.
- Do not publish only five-star feedback if it gives a false picture of what customers usually say. You do not have to publish every comment, but what you publish should be fair.
- Do not claim results the customer did not actually experience.
If you work in a regulated profession, check your regulator's advertising rules as well, since some restrict testimonials. Our guide to website design for professional services firms mentions this.
Always get permission
A testimonial contains a person's words, and often their name, photo or business details. Before you publish it, get clear permission that covers where and how you will use it, such as on your website, in social media posts and in printed materials. Written permission is best, and an email reply is fine. Let the customer choose how they are named: full name, first name and neighbourhood, or initials. Some customers, particularly business customers, may need approval from their own organization.
Also consider privacy. Avoid sharing details that identify someone's home, health, finances or other private matters unless they have specifically agreed. Our guide to website privacy policies in Canada explains how to handle personal information responsibly. If a customer later asks you to remove a testimonial, remove it promptly.
When and how to ask
The best time to ask is right after a good moment: a finished project, a delivered order or a compliment the customer has just given you. Keep the request short, personal and easy to say yes to. For example: "Thank you again for choosing us. If you were happy with the work, would you be willing to share a few sentences about your experience? We would love to include it on our website, with your permission."
Some options that make it easier for customers:
- Send a short email with two or three questions rather than an open request.
- Offer a simple form with a few prompts.
- Offer to take notes during a call, then send the wording for approval.
- Ask a follow-up question when someone gives verbal praise, then ask if you may quote them.
Ask questions that produce useful answers
Customers often write "Great service, thanks" when they are left to their own devices. Good prompts draw out specifics:
- What problem were you trying to solve?
- What was it like working with us?
- What was the outcome, in your own words?
- Would you recommend us, and to whom?
Specific comments are more believable than general praise, and they help future customers see themselves in the story.
Edit lightly and keep the customer's voice
You can fix obvious typos and trim a rambling passage, but do not change the meaning or polish the personality out of it. If you shorten a longer message, share the shortened version with the customer for approval. Use ellipses where you have removed text, and never put words in someone's mouth.
Display testimonials where they help
Testimonials work best near the moment of decision, not hidden on a page nobody visits.
- Home page: a short selection near the top, so visitors see social proof early.
- Service pages: a testimonial that relates to that specific service, placed near the call to action.
- Contact or booking pages: a short reassurance close to the form.
- A dedicated page: a longer collection for visitors who want to read more.
Our guide to turning website visitors into enquiries explains how to place trust signals alongside clear next steps.
Make them look credible
- Include a name, and where appropriate a business, neighbourhood or town, because anonymous quotes carry less weight.
- Add a real photo only if the customer is happy to share one.
- Keep the design simple and legible, with enough contrast for everyone to read.
- Show the date or project type if it helps.
- Mix short quotes and one or two longer ones.
Avoid sliding carousels that move too quickly to read, and avoid stock photos of smiling strangers. Our post on original photos versus stock photos explains why.
Link to the original where you can
If a testimonial began as a public review on Google or another platform, linking to the original lets visitors check it for themselves, which builds trust. Whether you display live reviews or quoted excerpts, make sure what you show reflects what the platform says.
Keep them fresh
A page full of testimonials from several years ago can suggest a business that has stopped trying. Review your testimonials a few times a year, add new ones, and retire any that no longer reflect how you operate. This fits neatly into a regular website maintenance routine.
If you would like help planning where trust-building content belongs on your website, you are welcome to get in touch for a free conversation.